Larry Henderson: Rodney Hinton Files $25 Million Federal Lawsuit Over Detention, Alleged Abuse, and Intimidation Following Arrest in Deputy’s Death

On May 2, 2025, Rodney Hinton Jr., 38, allegedly struck and killed Hamilton County Sheriff’s Deputy Larry Henderson with his vehicle near the University of Cincinnati. The incident followed the fatal police shooting of Hinton’s son, Ryan Hinton, on May 1. Hinton was arrested and charged with aggravated murder. On May 8, he filed a $25 million federal lawsuit alleging excessive force, intimidation, and unlawful detention.

Victim

• Larry Henderson: A 33-year veteran deputy, killed while directing traffic on May 2, 2025. Known for service in specialized units, his death prompted widespread law enforcement support.

Lawsuit Allegations

• Excessive Force: Hinton claims he was subjected to excessive force during his arrest, resulting in visible head injuries seen during his May 3 arraignment.
• Courtroom Intimidation: Dozens of officers packed Hinton’s arraignment and bond hearings, creating an “atmosphere of fear, surveillance, and intimidation.” His orange jumpsuit was cited as unusual and prejudicial.
• Unlawful Detention: The lawsuit alleges Hinton was detained without a meaningful bond hearing or conviction, violating due process.
• Conspiracy: Authorities allegedly conspired to discriminate and intimidate Hinton, targeting him due to his race and emotional state.

Legal Context

• Charges: Hinton faces aggravated murder and felonious assault charges, with a possible death penalty. A grand jury indicted him on May 8.
• Defense: Attorney Clyde Bennett II entered a not guilty plea, potentially by reason of insanity, citing Hinton’s mental state after his son’s death. A competency evaluation is requested.
• Bond Hearings: Judge Tyrone Yates ordered Hinton held without bond on May 3 and May 6, citing public safety. Hearings were marked by chaos and heavy police presence.

Community Impact

The case has polarized Cincinnati, with law enforcement honoring Henderson and Hinton’s supporters alleging racial bias. Viral body camera footage and X posts highlight public concerns about police intimidation and systemic racism. The Hinton family seeks answers about Ryan’s death, amplifying discussions about police use of force.

Broader Implications

The lawsuit raises issues of race, mental health, and judicial fairness. It may influence how police presence in courtrooms is managed and how pretrial detention is conducted, amid Cincinnati’s history of racial tensions.

Conclusion

Hinton’s lawsuit and the death of Larry Henderson reflect a complex tragedy involving grief, alleged misconduct, and systemic challenges. The case demands transparency and accountability to ensure justice for all parties.